“Behind the Counter” report reveals retailers concealing prohibited products from view and raises concerns over gaps in enforcement of the City’s flavored-vape ban
NEW YORK – Today, New York City Council Speaker Julie Menin released a new report detailing the findings of an investigation conducted by the Council’s Oversight and Investigations Division (OID) into the availability of prohibited flavored e-cigarettes, and the prevalence of unlawful advertising of tobacco- and e-cigarette advertisements near New York City Schools. Flavored e-cigarettes, or “vapes,” are prohibited for sale in New York City, yet they remain readily available near many of the City’s public middle and high schools. While some retailers openly display prohibited flavored vapes, many others kept them hidden from view, only revealing their inventory when customers ask for what’s behind the counter.
The investigative findings and recommendations are contained in a report prepared by OID, Behind the Counter.
“The findings of our investigation are deeply concerning and underscore the need for stronger oversight of flavored e-cigarette sales, particularly near our city’s public schools” said New York City Council Speaker Julie Menin. “We have a responsibility to protect our young people from the dangers of nicotine addiction, and that means ensuring the laws we pass to keep harmful products out of their hands are being effectively enforced. I want to thank the Council’s Oversight and Investigations Division for their thorough work on this report, and the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection for their collaboration and continued commitment to protecting New Yorkers.”
In 2019, the New York City Council passed Local Law 228, which banned the sale of any flavored e-cigarette, and the following year, the State amended its Public Health Law to add similar restrictions. A flavored e-cigarette is defined as an electronic cigarette with a “characterizing flavor,” in that it imparts a flavor that is distinguishable from tobacco flavor. New York State Law also prohibits businesses located within 500 feet of a school from displaying e-cigarette-related advertisements.
Investigators from OID posed as customers soliciting prohibited flavored vapes at 193 retailers located within 500 feet of a New York City public middle or high school, including both licensed e-cigarette retailers and unlicensed retailers that had received recent tobacco- or e-cigarette-related complaints. Investigators observed the following:
- Of the 201 schools analyzed, 32% had a retailer within 500 feet offering prohibited flavored vapes, while 35% had a nearby retailer displaying prohibited tobacco or e-cigarette advertisements or smoking paraphernalia.
- Among surveyed businesses selling e-cigarettes, 40% offered prohibited flavors, while an additional 43% offered products labeled as “clear”-flavored but no other identifiable prohibited flavors. In total, 83% of e-cigarette sellers offered either prohibited flavors or “clear”-labeled products. The labeling raises concerns that these products may circumvent the flavored e-cigarette ban, by marketing products as unflavored when they have a distinguishable non-tobacco taste or by using the “clear” labeling to disguise prohibited flavors.
- Of 101 DCWP-licensed retailers offering e-cigarettes for sale, over a quarter offered at least one identifiable prohibited flavor. All of the 28 unlicensed retailers offering e-cigarettes for sale offered prohibited flavored products.
- The report also uncovered significant enforcement concerns, including approximately $1.12 million in penalties issued to businesses without active e-cigarette licenses, but with recorded payments amounting to just 0.5% of those penalties.
“I’m thankful for the hard work of our Council’s Oversight and Investigations Division, which found an alarming number of retailers selling illegal flavored vapes near New York City schools,” said Council Member Shekar Krishnan, Chair of the Committee on Oversight and Investigations. “The health of our students will always come before the profit of businesses— big or small. I look forward to holding an Oversight hearing on this issue and ensuring we hold businesses accountable who are breaking our laws and endangering our students’ health.”
“While flavored vapes have been banned in New York City since 2019, the City Council’s Oversight and Investigations Division found that they continue to be illegally sold and advertised near our middle and high schools,” said Council Member Harvey Epstein, Chair of the Committee on Consumer and Worker Protection. “64% of surveyed students reported that vaping is common at their school, we cannot afford to look the other way. We need stronger enforcement, increased public awareness of the serious health risks, and accountability for the businesses that continue to put young people in danger. I applaud Speaker Menin for leading the charge to make sure that our children grow up free from the illegal influence of these dangerous products.”
The report recommends the following:
- DWCP should determine the compliance status of e-cigarettes marketed or labeled as “clear”-flavored, investigate how “clear”-labeling is being used to obscure prohibited e-cigarette flavors, and issue public guidance accordingly.
- DCWP and the New York State Department of Health (NYS DOH) should strengthen enforcement of advertising and display restrictions near schools, prioritizing inspections of businesses near schools for compliance.
- The Administration, including DCWP, the Department of Health and Mental Hygiene (DOHMH), and the Department of Education (DOE) should coordinate retail enforcement with youth-facing public-health messaging, including explaining the health risks of youth vaping and the legal restrictions on flavored vapes.
- DCWP, the Office of Administrative Trials and Hearings (OATH), and the Department of Finance (DOF) should review the substantial penalties, recorded payments, and outstanding balances associated with repeat violations. Agencies should consider what enforcement mechanisms are at their disposal to promote compliance among retailers.
The Council’s Committees on Oversight and Investigations and Consumer and Worker Protection will hold a joint oversight hearing on Friday to examine the report’s findings and recommendations, hear testimony from the Department of Consumer and Worker Protection on its current enforcement practices, and identify opportunities for the Council to strengthen the City’s enforcement efforts.
The Council will also hear Introduction 1167, sponsored by Council Member Mercedes Narcisse, which would grant DCWP the authority to use their sealing power to shut down businesses for the repeated sale of prohibited e-cigarettes.
“Our kids should be able to walk back and forth to school without being targeted by unscrupulous smoke shop owners selling illegal flavored vapes, said Council Member Mercedes Narcisse, Chair of the Committee on Hospitals. “When these shops sell vapes that are already illegal, a fine itself just becomes the cost of doing business. Intro. 1167 gives DCWP the authority to shut these businesses down. I thank Speaker Menin and the Oversight and Investigations Division for this report and look forward to passing this important bill to help protect the health and well-being of our youth.”
“E-Cigarette flavors like fruit, candy, and dessert can make these products particularly appealing to young people, putting our children at greater risk of nicotine addiction and its lasting health consequences,” said Council Member Lynn Schulman, Chair of the Committee on Health. “Our children deserve to grow up in communities that protect their health and well-being, not expose them to products that can harm their development. I want to thank Speaker Julie Menin for her leadership in bringing attention to this issue. These findings underscore the need for meaningful enforcement of our existing public health protections and accountability for businesses that violate the law. Protecting the health and well-being of our children must remain a priority.”
“As a teacher, I always worried about my students’ health and well-being,” said Council Member Eric Dinowitz, Chair of the Committee on Education. “As a Council Member, I remain worried. This report shows that nearly a third of the schools analyzed have a store within 500 feet selling flavored vapes that are already banned, and most of those stores keep them behind the counter until a kid asks. I thank Speaker Menin and the Oversight and Investigations Division for this investigation, and I look forward to working with DCWP and DOE to keep our students safe.”
“We are proud to work alongside the New York City Council to crack down on the illegal sale of flavored vapes, particularly in the areas surrounding our public schools, where our children and young people deserve to be protected,” said Commissioner Samuel A.A. Levine, Department of Consumer and Worker Protection. “This collaboration reflects the Mamdani Administration’s commitment to strengthening enforcement, holding bad actors accountable, and ensuring businesses comply with the law. We look forward to continuing our partnership with the Council to protect New Yorkers and keep these harmful products out of our communities.”
“It is unacceptable that businesses can continue selling prohibited flavored vapes, even in close proximity to schools, while facing so little meaningful accountability,” said Caroline Joyce, Executive Director of Parents Against Vaping (PAVe). “The fact that only a tiny fraction of the fines issued have been paid, and that the City’s sealing authority has never been used solely for these violations, raises serious questions about whether current enforcement efforts are enough. Retailers should not be able to treat the law as optional. Protecting our youth and young people requires consistent enforcement and real consequences.”
“During 2023-25, we collaborated with NYC Public Schools to train hundreds of teachers in the evidence-based CATCH My Breath program, which they brought to tens of thousands of students,” said Duncan Van Dusen, Founder & CEO of CATCH Global Foundation. “The results of this initiative show that teens are uniquely vulnerable to flavored vapes, but that skills-based prevention programming can teach them to resist the temptations that the industry, retailers, and media are constantly putting in front of them. In addition to supply curbs, we can succeed by addressing the demand side of the equation in parallel.”
“It is deeply concerning that flavored e-cigarettes continue to be sold in New York City, especially by retailers near schools, despite city and state laws prohibiting the sale of these products,” said Kevin O’Flaherty, Associate Vice-President, State and Local Advocacy at Campaign for Tobacco-Free Kids. “This investigation underscores the urgent need for the city and the state to step up enforcement of these laws in order to protect kids. Inspectors must have the full range of tools necessary to enforce these laws and hold bad actors accountable. We applaud Speaker Menin and the New York City Council for their leadership on this important issue.”
###